In a recent news article by Kathryn May, Liberal MPs are arguing that new RCMP Commissioner William Elliott and certain political elite have a relationship that is "too cozy." More Specifically, Public Safety Minister Stockwell Day has been criticized by Liberal MPs for a lack of formality in what should be formal communication with William Elliott. For example, Day not only addresses him as 'Bill' in formal emails etc, but also appears to have a very 'chumy' relationship with him. Furthermore, the Liberals seemingly question Elliott's worthiness of his position.
My Critique
First, it is importsnt to have some degree of separation and level of professionalism among the leaders we empower. However, only to certain extent. In other words, co-workers referring to eachother by their first name in emails is so insignificant in the whole scheme of things. Also, whether or not the Commissioner has been in the line of duty and told "if you're a cop I'll kill you" is irrelevant. That is, Elliot's ability to manage and essentially lead our national police force is based on his core competencies, not the bullets he's taken. In reality, it seems the Liberals are making a lackluster effort to simply damage the Conservative image.
Advocacy of the Devil
Those who represent such important entities in government must always conduct themselves professionally-especially because they are often under the public eye. The leader of Canada's police force should be referred to formally. Moreover, it is fair to say that leaders or managers who have never experienced the front lines may be less effective. Can Elliott command the the necessary respect for being a national police commissioner? Well, his lack of direct police action doesn't strengthen his image.
No comments:
Post a Comment